BOTH SIDES OF THE GUN

Gun Control Advocates Call Clinton a Hypocrite

Jake Tapper ABC News

February 05, 2008 8:19 AM

Yesterday we took a look at Sen. Barack Obama's pro-hunter preaching in Idaho, wondering how it fit with a 1996 questionnaire in which he supported banning all handguns. Sen. Hillary Clinton implied Obama was a flip-flopper. (Read more HERE.)

This aroused the ire of some gun control advocates, who pointed out that even if one considers this an Obama flip-flop (and Obama says that questionnaire was filled out incorrectly by a staffer), Clinton has made a much more dramatic flip.

In an email to me, Andy Pelosi of Gun Free Kids, writes, "quite frankly, there are many gun control advocates that find it distasteful that Clinton appears to be running to the right of Obama on guns."

Running for the Senate in 2000, Clinton appeared before newspaper publishers in May of that year to say that gun control was part of the raison d'etre for her Senate campaign.

"We have to do more to stand up to those who refuse to believe the reality that guns do kill and that common-sense gun measures can make a difference," she said to the Newspaper Association of America's annual convention in New York. "I believe we need a comprehensive plan to stop gun violence, and it is one of the reasons I am running for the Senate."

Part of this, she said, was a national gun registry.

"We license drivers before they get behind the wheel to make sure they can drive safely," she said. "We register cars to make sure someone is responsible for every vehicle on the road. But we don't do the same for deadly weapons."

But last month she backed off this proposal.

At a Democratic debate in Nevada she said something different.

She said she was against "illegal guns," she said she wanted to get guns "out of the hands of young people," she called for a registry of "felons, people who have been committed to mental institutions like the man in Virginia Tech who caused so much death and havoc" and "we need to enforce the laws that we have on the books. I would also work to reinstate the assault-weapons ban."

These are generally the steps supported by the Republican presidential candidates as well. Which is fine - but it's quite different from how she sounded in 2000, when she was calling for far more liberal gun control measures.

"You know, I believe in the Second Amendment. People have a right to bear arms," Clinton said at the Nevada debate, "but I also believe that we can common-sensically approach this."

Inquired Tim Russert, "But you've backed off a national licensing registration plan?"

"Yes," Clinton said.

Bryan Miller, Executive Director of Ceasefire NJ , writes that "Clinton"s attack (on Obama on guns) is an obvious effort to frighten some with the false specter of gun confiscation under an Obama presidency, a prospect that is clearly not in the cards in this country, whoever is in office."

He goes on: "Clinton's attack is highly ironic, as well, both because she has changed positions on guns even more rapidly than Obama..." He says "there's more than a bit of the pot calling the kettle in Clinton's carefully parsed, but transparent and toxic attack. So, not only is Clinton's arithmetic incorrect as to Obama's so-called 'rapidly changes position,' but her own stated stance on gun regulation has both changed dramatically and done so in a much shorter time frame. No hypocrisy there, right?"

Somebody's daughter, somebody's son
There's somebody's brother on both sides of the gun
There's something so wrong that must be undone
When someone is hurt and means to hurt someone

Every injustice, every poison
Every deception touches every one

It's a sad story like so many I know
Through the cracks of the system they let the man go
He devastated my family, he widowed a wife
A thousand miles away, he touched my life

Every injustice, every poison
Every deception touches everyone
It's every daughter, it's every son
The people who meet on both sides of the gun

Somebody's daughter, somebody's son
There's somebody's brother on both sides of the gun
There's something so wrong that must be undone
We can all make a difference one by one

Every oppression every denial
Every corruption connects every one

I can't believe God would ever approve
Of teaching so many to hate and exclude
We put so much energy into power and greed
Dismissing the things that we really need
And moving so fast we miss so much
We should remember our conscience and get back in touch
If we could focus our power on this one thing
Maybe some of this madness might stop happening

Every injustice, every poison
Every lie touches everyone
Every brother, it's every one
The people who meet on both sides of the gun

Every religion that teaches our children
We can wait until the next life to stand accountable

Every action every crime
Every time - we're all responsible ...on both sides

Every sister, every brother
Take care of each other ...on both sides

Hey Mother,Hey Father
Reach out to your children ...on both sides

Every injustice every poison
Every deception connects all of us

Every corruption, every denial
Every oppression touches all of us

Every rejection , every hate crime
Every cry touches all of us

Every outrage every bias
Every lie touches all of us

Every kindness, every compassion
Every miracle connects all of us

Every promise, every mercy
Every helping hand touches all of us

In every city, in every country
Every connection touches all of us ...on both sides

Every brother, every sister
Every life is indispensible ...on both sides

Every sister, every brother
Take care of each other ...on both sides

Every father, every mother
Let's all get together ...on both sides

Every brother, every sister
Every life ...on both sides